For the second time in two weeks, the Hutchinson City Council reviewed its financial plans for 2024 and once again the public showed little interest.

The annual Truth-In-Taxation hearing last week drew a couple of residents and one business owner.

“The reason that hopefully you’re here tonight … is to enhance the public participation in the property tax system by allowing the public forum to discuss the proposed budget, proposed tax levies, talk about increase of or explain increases in the bulk of budget,” City Administrator Matt Jaunich said.

The preliminary tax levy, initially sent out in September, proposed a city tax increase of 9.3%, with a balanced budget. However, revisions have been made, and the revised budget includes a 7.2% tax levy increase. This adjustment reflects changes in revenue and expense projections, resulting in the elimination of approximately $178,000 in taxes since the adoption of the preliminary budget in September.

A home valued at $250,000 will see a $131 increase in taxes next year.

Jaunich compared Hutchinson to other cities in McLeod County, highlighting Hutchinson’s position in property tax rates.

“Hutchinson had the second lowest tax rate in 2023,” he said.

In McLeod County for 2023, Biscay had the lowest city property tax at 44.65%, Hutchinson was the second-lowest coming in at 53.65%, while Stewart had the highest property tax at 131.65%.

“One thing I do like to note because the question comes up is that the city taxes are extremely high and my question is compared to what or compared to who,” Jaunich said.

When comparing 19 outstate regional centers for 2022, Hutchinson ranked in the middle of the pack with a 60.41% tax rate, dispelling the notion that the city’s taxes are exceptionally high compared to others.

“The average city tax (state-wide) is 74.65%. So, when you look at overall, we’re below the state average, we’re kind of middle of the pack in regards to outstate regional centers and we’re on the low side when it comes to other cities within the county.”

The proposed budget for 2024 revealed a 9.1% increase in the general fund tax levy, marking the ninth consecutive year of increase. Juanich reminded the council of the city’s mission statement and core values, emphasizing the alignment of budget decisions with key focus areas.

“The city of Hutchinson exists with our residents, businesses and property owners and visitors are provided with quality services and programs that support a safe, healthy, sustainable and business friendly community with a small-town atmosphere for our possibly government, similar to our less than comparable outstate Minnesota cities,” he said.

In terms of expenses, the city projected a 3.7% increase in the general fund, allocating funds to various departments and highlighting the impact of rising wages, benefits, and supply costs.

“Once again, that (wages and benefits) is our highest expenditure within our fund is the cost for the employees,” Jaunich said. “We see an increase in supplies of about 8.7%. Once again, that’s directly related to inflation and as most of us are seeing in our day-to-day lives, the costs to operate at the city, those fees or those expenses are higher than what we’ve been seeing in the past. It’s the same for services and charges.”

The enterprise funds were also discussed which included Hutch Liquor, Creekside compost, refuse, water, wastewater and stormwater system.

“I like to highlight some of our enterprise funds just so the public is aware of that, Juanich said. “Once again, no tax dollars go into these funds. These are all funded by the service fees that the various different departments collect.”

Jaunich outlined the proposed revenues and expenses for the each of the enterprise funds for 2024.

“The liquor store, we need to buy a new refrigerator freezer, we need to make upgrades to the counters,” he said. “That’s where if you see a negative cash balance, it’s done by design, it’s on purpose. We’re using cash to pay for those needed improvements.”

Quick facts about enterprise funds were shared, indicating that the liquor store and Creekside funds continued to perform well, contributing over $670,000 to the general fund. However, a 5% increase in garbage rates for 2024 was proposed due to rising costs, including increased hauling and disposal rates. Other enterprise funds maintained healthy balances, with only a slight increase in stormwater rates.

“With those transfers-in, the creekside and the liquor store and stuff, that really helps us to keep our services up at a high level,” Mayor Gary Forcier said.

The meeting also delved into the city’s 2024-2028 five-year capital improvement plan, highlighting investment of approximately $70 million in various city aspects. The breakdown included allocations for:

• Infrastructure $23.35 million

• Enterprise funds $19.99 million

• Public Works $15.2 million

• Parks and Recreation $6.36 million

• Public safety $3.28 million

• General government $1.18 million

Funding sources for these capital improvements were a mix of state aid, federal aid, donations, enterprise funds, new debt, taxes, special assessments, and special fund reserves, Jaunich asked.

Resident Jim Lauer asked about the city’s enterprise funds, particularly focusing on the utilities sector. He noted that despite revenues being consistently less than expenses in the annual budget reports, there is a surplus being transferred back to the city.

“Where’s that magic math happen or is it somewhere else,” he said.

City Finance Director Andy Reid explained that depreciation is a necessary accounting practice used to reflect the decreasing value of facilities and infrastructure in financial statements. He said that, in the case of utilities like wastewater, the annual depreciation expense can be significant, such as $1.8 million. This depreciation cost contributes to a negative net revenue on the profit and loss statement, but it’s crucial to understand that depreciation is not an actual cash expense. Instead, it represents an accounting measure to set aside funds for future replacement of facilities and infrastructure.

“You pull depreciation out of our profit and loss statement and all of a sudden we’ve got cash flow of maybe a million dollars,” he said.

Lauer also expressed interest in obtaining detailed departmental budgets to better understand the allocation of funds, particularly in relation to personnel, such as the police department.

The next step is for City Council to approve the final budget and levies a its Dec 19 meeting and then certify the final levies to the county by Dec. 30.

“One thing is we all live here, we all pay the same taxes, so we make sure we’re doing the best we can to keep the taxes low,” Forcier said.