Mounting concerns over the expansion of a dairy farm just east of Hutchinson city limits have prompted calls from the city and McLeod County Board for a third-party review of the plans.
Skyview Dairy has proposed increasing its herd size, growing from 2,540 animal units to 3,520. Under the county’s joint planning ordinance with Hutchinson, any expansion exceeding 399 animal units requires a conditional use permit.
Hutchinson Joint Planning Committee deferred a decision on the conditional use permit until its June 20 meeting and recommended the McLeod County Board authorize a third-party consultant to review an environmental assessment worksheet of the proposed expansion from 2020. The McLeod County Feedlot Committee also recommended the review.
“I’m not a soil scientist as staff,” Environmental Services Director Marc Telecky said. “I can’t determine permeability rates in regards to application and what that effect would be on groundwater. That’s typically what an environmental consultant would do.”
Luthens Family LLC Skyview Dairy voluntarily conducted an environmental assessment worksheet in 2020, but opted to withdraw an expansion application at that time. In January this year, the Luthens Family resubmitted its expansion application, along with the 4-year-old EAW.
Tom Dahl, chairman of the Hutchinson Area Joint Planning Committee, expressed skepticism about the credibility and completeness of the EAW, noting that the document was unsigned and undated.
“That was a red flag for me,” he said. “I tried to understand why this is not signed and dated. Who reviewed it? Who’s the person with their credentials? Somehow we’re using this word voluntary, and to me, it’s like whether it’s voluntary or not, it still needs to be certified so that I know that it’s accurate and correct.”
Dahl pointed out several items in the document, highlighting one page where four items were flagged for scrutiny. On another page, only one item raised questions, while subsequent pages included three or four items noted for further consideration.
“I’m on the committee that’s supposed to be doing the boots-on-the-ground and I got so many questions on the document that aren’t answered,” he said.
The EAW reported quantities of manure, totaling about 19 million gallons, were deemed accurate to the best of their knowledge. However, Dahl highlighted a discrepancy in following statement, which indicated 191,000 gallons for one type and 191,881,674 gallons for another.
“I think we need to know the difference between 19 million and 191 million gallons,” he said. “There’s lots of stuff in this document that I think are inaccurate or mistyped or not fully understood how to answer.”
The city represents one member of the six-member joint planning board. Discussions within the city’s internal management team have not revealed any negative impacts from the feedlot expansion thus far, Hutchinson Planning and Zoning Director Dan Jochum said. However, officials want to understand the potential implications of the expansion, particularly given its increased scale.
“I think from the city’s perspective we’d just like to understand what the potential impacts might be,” Jochum said. “Then we have more information to … have an opinion on whether or not the expansion should occur or not occur.”
An EAW is required for expansions over 1,000 animal units.
“The expansions have been under that, but now we’re getting up over 3,000 animal units total,” Jochum said. “The idea that the largest city is within a mile of a feedlot, I think planning (board) in general is looking out for the future and it might be that there’s no issue and it might be we have to consider some mitigation efforts maybe to make sure that there isn’t an impact to the feedlot or to the city or the township or whatnot.”
McLeod County Board Chairman Paul Wright emphasized the importance of the livestock industry in Minnesota, highlighting its significant economic impact. He acknowledged the challenges arising from the proximity of the county’s largest city to its largest feedlot, emphasizing the need to address potential conflicts between agricultural practices and urban communities.
Wright advocated for thorough documentation, such as a vetted EAW, to provide a transparent basis for decision-making and streamline approval processes for agricultural projects.
“I think the thought process is we need some truth and documentation,” he said. “Verify that the EAW, whether it gets sent to the EQB board (Environmental Quality Board) or we work with one of the other consultant firms to do one, gives us an official document to lie on that has been vetted publicly through those channels. I think we need an insurance policy. I think (that) is what those boards are asking for is to be able to fall back and say it was vetted through this channel, there’s nothing better that can be done.”
He clarified that the intention is not to hinder agricultural growth but to ensure responsible coexistence between agricultural operations and neighboring communities. By obtaining comprehensive documentation, the aim is to streamline the approval process for projects like the expansion of the feedlot. This approach mitigates the need for excessive regulatory conditions, which could impede agricultural development, Wright said.
He also stressed the goal of preventing adverse interactions between agricultural and residential areas, which often lead to the imposition of new regulations. As a farmer, Wright noted the importance of addressing issues at the local level to avoid further regulatory.
Garrett Luthens, manager at Skyview Dairy, stressed his adherence to state regulations overseen by the Minnesota Department of Agriculture, citing his preference for initiating permit applications with the state due to comprehensive oversight.
Commissioner Nathan Schmalz stressed the necessity of following correct procedures and ensuring transparency in the process. Expressing regret over the need for additional scrutiny, he highlighted the importance of an independent review to maintain integrity and thoroughness in the evaluation process.
“I think we need to do that for the protection of the county, the board that I represent and also for the protection of the family involved,” he said.
Commissioner Daryl Luthens, father of Garrett Luthens and co-owner of Skyview, who sat out the vote raised concerns about the necessity of an EAW, citing an existing 22-page agreement with the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency and Skyview Dairy.
“I don’t know what the EAW is going to do extra,” he said. “I think we’re asking for something not needed.”
The county will work with Skyview Dairy to select an independent third-party reviewer.
“I just think it needs to be reviewed and signed off by somebody that’s accredited or reviewed for 30 days by people that are experts,” Dahl said. “We are not.”


