Minnesota is getting a new state flag and seal next year, and not everyone is happy about it.
Or at least they question the need for change.
The State Emblem Redesign Commission overseeing the collection and final approval of designs started its work in September, acting after the Legislature passed a law requiring the work.
“The problem was, in the minds of some people, and I appreciate this, is that they think that there are racial implications, ” state Rep. Dean Urdahl said of the current flag, which was adopted in 1957.
The commission received more than 2,000 submissions for the new flag and seal designs.
Last week, the commission narrowed the designs to six finalists with the common theme being green, blue and white colors with the North Star added onto the design.
Minnesota's original state flag design was created in 1893 by Amelia Hyde Center. The design was revised over time. In 1957, minor design changes were made to the seal and the background color was made a solid blue. The seal was redrawn in 1983 and the blue color was lightened, marking the final changes.
However, the journey to change the current flag’s design hasn’t been a smooth one.
“I know there have been a lot of concerns about indigenous voices in regards to the artwork that's portrayed on the (current) flag,” New Century Academy teacher Kelsey Dolge said. “I know there is a lot more color than what you'll find in most typical state flags. And I know I read about this: There are five keys to a decent flag or whatever, and I think the Minnesota state flag, in the study that I read, violated all five of them.”
The North American Vexillological Society, a source listed by the state commission, lists five elements of a good flag design, including:
- keep it simple,
- use meaningful symbolism,
- use only two or three basic colors,
- do not use lettering or seals,
- and be distinctive or related.
But effort to change the flag and seal has created division.
“In general, I am opposed to tearing down artifacts of state or national history to avoid offending the sensibilities of modern society,” Litchfield High School teacher Adam Hayes said. “It does not benefit us to censor our history and suppress it. Shameful atrocities were committed in American history between the indigenous peoples of the United States and settlers of Minnesota. The danger of modern society ripping up statues and symbols and forgetting its history – warts and all – outweighs the benefits of pacifying an unappeasable activist class.”
Urdahl said he didn’t see racial implications in the current flag and didn’t support changing its design.
“I do recognize that a bill was passed to create a commission to change the state flag, and it's going to happen,” he said. “So with that in mind, I have accepted the fact we're going to have a different state flag. All I encourage is that some of the basic tenets of our current flag remain, like the color and you got to have something in the circle, like the North Star.”
While Urdahl and Hayes oppose the changes, New Century Academy teachers Chris Smith and Dolge favor the change.
“Everything needs a fresh perspective,” Smith said. “We're constantly growing and evolving and changing. I think a new state flag is a great idea.”
“I would want our flag to be something that is easy to recognize and a little less congested, and any voices that are being included should actually be from those communities,” Dolge said.
Brian Beffert a government teacher at Hutchinson High School said he is neutral about the process.
“I'm not for or against, it's just what the state wants to do,” he said. “And if that's what the majority of state legislature votes for and they have a fair process, then that's one thing that they decide to do. So, obviously, they've decided that they want the flag updated. And their job is to listen to both sides and take a vote.”
The new flag will fly May 11, 2024, on Statehood Day unless the Legislature rejects the commission's decision.


