A Hutchinson man is one of four individuals who are currently facing federal charges related to an alleged catalytic converter theft operation valued at $21 million dollars.
The charges filed on Oct. 18 and include defendants, John Charles Kotten, 41 of Hutchinson; Justin Tyme Johnson, 32, of St. Paul; James Dillon Jensen, 34, of Minneapolis; and Soe Nye Moo, 31, of St. Paul.
The Department of Justice noted in the indictment the operation was believed to have been active between May 2020 and October 2022. The operations goal was to transport stolen catalytic converter parts from Minnesota and other location and sell them to buyers.
For gasoline and diesel cars, a catalytic converter serves as an add-on component within the exhaust system. Its primary function is to transform and diminish harmful emissions emitted by the vehicle’s engine. Precious metals including platinum, palladium and rhodium are inside the converter and are worth thousands of dollars.
Catalytic converter thefts have become a growing concern in both Minnesota and across the nation, with these stolen parts being sold to buyers before being melted down for their valuable metals. About $19 million of the conspiracy’s proceeds came from “high-volume” buyers located in New Jersey, Oklahoma, Colorado and New York.
As part of the conspiracy, individuals who operated as street-level cutters stole catalytic converters from vehicles throughout the state of Minnesota and transferred them to Kotten or Johnson, according to the Department of Justice. At times, Kotten and Johnson met with cutters directly to buy stolen catalytic converters, other times they instructed cutters to transfer the catalytic converters to intermediary buyers acting on their behalf, such as Jensen and Moo.
After receiving stolen catalytic converters, the defendants concealed and stored the inventory in preparation for shipment across state lines. After sorting, categorizing, and pricing out the anticipated loads, the defendants transported the stolen catalytic converters across state lines using rented U-Haul trailers and personal vehicles. Payments for the stolen catalytic converters were typically in the form of wire transfer, cash, check, or a combination thereof.
In order to conceal their scheme, Kotten and others purchased scrap or junk cars from individual sellers or at auction to make it appear as though they were involved in a legitimate automotive scrapping and recycling business in the event they were audited or investigated.
The defendants were granted conditional releases before their upcoming court appearance. They face various charges, including conspiracy to transport stolen property across state lines, along with separate individual charges. Additionally, Moo faces a charge for possessing a machinegun, while Kotten and Johnson face charges related to transporting stolen property, conspiracy to commit money laundering and making false statements to a financial institution. Johnson also faces a separate change of conspiracy to commit money laundering.



